We Want Your Writing.

The Thickness of Water

When Christopher and I were children, we dreamed of swimming to a small island just off the shore of Popham Beach. The island was visible from all the way down the sandy coast, but if we walked for an hour to get to where the shoreline bent ninety degrees, and if the tide was right, only a narrow strip of ocean would separate it from the beach. Here, the water was clear and flat, marked occasionally by a small, gentle swell that had made its way over from the riptides where it met the greater ocean. In these moments, we would walk down the wide expanse of sand to the water’s edge—until our mother was a tiny figure on her towel—and look out to the island.
 
It was covered in pine trees, the kind that stood tall and straight and seemed to reach up into the sky in perfect dark green points, as if meticulously pruned by a gentle horticulturalist giant or a kind-hearted angel leaning out of the heavens. They reminded me of the conical plastic trees that came with an enchanted forest fairytale board game that Christopher and I liked to play, making up our own rules since he was too young to read the instructions and we both preferred to make up games anyway. Of course, Midcoast Maine was covered in pine trees and small islands, but what made this particular island special was the mansion that peeked out from within the pines, at the top of a winding path leading up from the shore.
 
From across the water, this mansion and the trees surrounding it had both an immaculate, toy-like appearance of a far-away dollhouse, and the impossibly sharp detail of a towering castle. To our young imaginations, the mansion was enchanted, and the entire island glimmered with the haze of magic hanging over it. How could a house be so large, so white, and emerge so tantalizingly from such perfect trees, if not for magic? What princes and princesses lived behind those doors; what fae frolicked among those branches?
 
Christopher and I loved to wade in that clear water, far enough away from our mother to enjoy a haven of independence—suspended in this strange, distant closeness to the island. One day, we brought a pair of snorkels our father had found at a yard sale and floated on our stomachs, gazing through the thick goggles at the sand that banked steeply away from the shore. At ten, I was already over five feet tall, but I could only comfortably touch the bottom for a few paces beyond the water’s edge before the ground dropped off. I figured it never got properly deep, though, since I could see the white-green sand well beyond where I could no longer set foot.
 
We doggy-paddled through these shallows, straying momentarily into the deep before coming back to root our toes in the ocean floor like kelp, trying not to choke on the brine that inevitably splashed into our masks every few seconds. It was unacceptable to even consider going home before the water glowed orange and fat horse flies started to gnaw at our shoulders. Sometimes we made up games, told each other stories or debated who would win in hypothetical Star Wars matchups. Other times, we lay in the shallows and kicked our feet, pretending we were merpeople. Or we made  sandcastles, Christopher the designated tower-builder, while I was responsible for the moat. When we raced each other, although he could barely swim more than ten feet at a time, I never pulled ahead, and he never grew tired of it.
 
We calculated how long it would take us to get to the other side of the strait: Just ten minutes, we said, Nah, even less. But we both understood it was hypothetical, because Christopher, three years younger and small for his age, never strayed far from the sandbank, and clung slickly to my bare arms in panic whenever his face dipped under the water.
 
In my mind, Christopher’s fear of the water was the one thing keeping us from the enchanted island. We’d both taken swimming lessons on and off for a while, weekly trips to the local Boys and Girls Club and later, briefly, to the YMCA in the next town over in hopes that the nicer pool would inspire Christopher to continue. Even so, he protested, my mother, trying futilely week after week to convince him to put on his bathing suit. He never gave a reason for hating it so much, and during my lessons I’d had to try and ignore his shrieks from the shallow end of the pool as his instructor pleaded with him to let go of the wall.
 
Eventually, unable to acclimatize to the feeling of being submerged, he was allowed to quit, but I continued with the lessons, a strong swimmer even as I grew increasingly uncomfortable with how I looked in my one-piece suit. I mastered all the basic strokes, perfecting and growing to love even the butterfly, which I’d struggled with at first. I looked forward to the hour every week where I could pull my swim cap over my ears and sink into the heavy warmth of the pool room, all sounds jumbling wordlessly together before disappearing into a dull murmur when I dove underwater.
 
Many years later, shortly before she was admitted to the first of many detox facilities and psychiatric hospitals, my mother called me into her darkened bedroom for a confession. I lay an arm’s length away, on sheets sweet with fermenting perspiration, as she recounted a story I barely remembered—her biggest failure as a mother: She had heeded an older woman’s complaint and abandoned her dear, young daughter—already too boyish for the women’s locker room—forcing me to change, alone, a little girl in the men’s room.
 
“It’s my fault you’re like this,” she said, “How could you still love your mother after what I’ve done?”
 
I lay, two arms and two legs stiffly on the bed, and imagined I was at the bottom of the pool, weightless, my body temperature equalizing with that of the water until I could no longer feel where I ended and the pool began.

 

*

 

Christopher is six, and he loves dinosaurs. Our father takes us to the natural history museum one Saturday, and I’m too young to wonder why our mother stays at home. He reads out loud from the plaques as we trace our hands over the replica footprints on display, our outstretched fingers dwarfed by the three-clawed imprints. Christopher grips my hand, his tiny palm equally dwarfed by mine, and his hair, our mother’s hair, is a shiny curtain off the back of his head as he tilts his face up toward the towering skeletons. They are bigger than anything I’ve ever seen, a single leg twice as tall as me. It’s almost impossible to imagine a world where creatures this large roamed the earth.
 
“These look like bones, but they’re actually not,” our father explains. Christopher doesn’t seem to be listening, leaning his head so far back I can feel that his grip on my hand is the only thing keeping him from toppling backward.
 
“Over time, minerals seep into the dinosaur’s bones and harden into rock while the bones themselves rot away. All these years later, we can still see the shape of the dinosaur, preserved into these fossils, but none of its actual body remains.”

 

*

 

No one knew exactly what happened to Christopher. Maybe, as many teenagers do, he found himself floating, suddenly untethered in the riptide of middle school and puberty, of homework, clumsily rolled joints, girls, and skipping class. But for one reason or another, he was unable to keep his face above the water. Instead, he dove headfirst into the vast world of video games and other distractions that offered him his first taste of escape into an alternate reality.
 
Maybe my mother tried to grab him, scrabbling too desperately for him. But the same small hands that had once held her hair off her sweaty forehead while I stood, paralyzed outside the bathroom, now pushed her away. They fought, loud and violent—our mother fueled by drink and a desperate, misguided maternal love, and Christopher by some fiery darkness that seemed to be hemorrhaging silently inside him, incomprehensible to its host and invisible to anyone else.
 
They both waited each night for my father to come home: She, eager to report Christopher’s transgressions from that afternoon in hopes my father would take her side and somehow regain control over the situation; he, ready to rebut and make a case for himself, taking full advantage of my father’s conflict-avoidant nature. The unspoken allegiance lines between my mother and Christopher and my father and me, allegiances of physical appearance and temperament that I had understood to be the established dynamic of our family, were completely dissolved. I observed these fiery kitchen-table litigations quietly; I admired Christopher’s ability to stand up to my mother and wind her up in knots, both of us knowing that the boundaries of any tenuous compromise they reached would be gradually manipulated until the next blow-up. I also hated him for the shamelessness with which he lied and ran circles around her confused attempts at law-laying. Even so, I found myself compelled, whenever my mother’s wild, bleary eyes looked to me for back-up, to side with my brother.
 
Maybe it was this dissonance between my simultaneous admiration and disdain that left me holding the space between them. Or maybe, along with my nose and hair texture, I’d inherited my father’s avoidant ambivalence, which  resulted in him offering only lukewarm and utterly unhelpful statements during arguments. Either way, I did the only thing I could think to do — I molded myself into a moderator, trying to talk them both down and simmering in secret, frigid disappointment when my efforts proved ultimately insufficient.
 
These fights continued almost nightly until eventually, Christopher stopped fighting back. He disappeared, little by little—his no-longer gap-toothed smile missing from the dinner table. They both did, Christopher and our mother, and when I’d get home after swim practice, I’d find my father waiting alone with a bland dish on the table and awkward non-conversation on his lips.
 
At first, Christopher went out late at night, mumbling the names of strange new friends as he rushed away, bag in hand. Then he no longer left the house, instead holing up in his room, smoke curling out from beneath his locked door. Sometimes other boys came and nodded shifty-eyed greetings before slinking upstairs, or he’d briefly step outside in sweatpants and socks to meet men in cars parked with their hazards on. His keyboard clicked long into the night and a few times a week, I’d wake up at 3 or 4 a.m. to hear him going downstairs for his secret nocturnal routines. During the day, he was a corpse under his quilt when anyone tried to wake him up to catch the last few periods of school. Before the end of his sophomore year, my parents signed the papers for Christopher to officially drop out of high school.
 
I went off to university without visiting the campus, driving the 500-mile trip alone after declining my mother’s offer to come along. She’d been hurt, and as I cruised down the interstate in my dad’s beat-up Subaru, I tried not to think about what the next few days back at home would look like. I was somewhat distracted by passive worries about what my roommate would be like or how the bathrooms were set up in the dorm, but beneath it all was only guilt and the quiet relief of escaping the dark, thick mold that had managed to creep over every surface in that house.
 
I couldn’t shake the feeling that by leaving, I was condemning each of them, each person I left behind, to rot from the inside out, but knew that by staying I would only be sentencing myself to the same fate. The friends I made that first year of college all happened to have siblings around Christopher’s age, and as they talked rambunctiously about what their siblings were up to back in their hometowns, I found myself silent, unwilling or unable to explain my own family’s situation. When my mother texted me in the middle of my Spring semester saying they were shipping Christopher off to a wilderness rehabilitation program a thousand miles away, I didn’t reply. Later that night, I started to type out a message to him but went to bed with the text unfinished and unsent.

 

*

 

The summer before my twenty-third birthday, I take two weeks off from work to visit home, and my mother wants to go to Maine. She’s two years sober, one hundred pounds lighter, and wakes up at six every morning to run five miles. When I look at her, I can almost forget who she used to be, but my stomach still drops when I mistake her nightly tea for a mug of wine—that had been the sheepish the evidence of a relapse dozens of times before.
 
One morning, we go to Popham Beach and jog on the sand together, my lungs burning keeping up with her. While her athletic ability has increased one-hundredfold in the past two years, mine has dwindled since I stopped swimming to recover from top surgery and never restarted. She chats while I pant heavily alongside her, our shared size-nine flat feet leaving deep, identical imprints in the sand.
 
“Do you remember how often I’d take you guys here, you and your brother, when you were little?”
 
I nod.
 
“Did you ever feel lonely in those long summers here without any friends and your father traveling for work?”
 
I choke out between breaths that I can’t remember.
 
“You know, I think now that it was unfair to you guys to take you with me,” she says. “I was really unwell at that time.”
 
My thighs and heels scream from the extra effort of jogging in the soft sand and I know that tomorrow I’ll be sore.
 
“I used to count the hours until it would be acceptable to have a drink, made myself wait until after sunset. It was easier to pass the time here while you two had fun on the beach until it was time to go home.”
 
She’s a graceful runner, and thin, much thinner than me now. Her sobriety and my hormone therapy have worked in opposite directions, and now that I am broader than I have ever been, her frame seems almost frail and skeletal.
 
“And you and your brother were so close back then, it was wonderful.” Her voice becomes wistful, unaffected by our brisk pace. “He loved you so much, he really looked up to you. He was always trying to show you things, impress you, play with you. ‘Hey Clara! Hey Clara!’ It was so sweet.”
 
If my throat was not suddenly blocked by my beating heart, I would surely reply.
 
How easily those words fall from her lips, the name that she gave me and that I called my own for sixteen years, cradled tenderly and often by Christopher’s sweet toddler’s tongue. I can tell that in her memory, the girl with that name and the boy with the gap-toothed smile are both preserved and untouched, and I wonder if she thinks of them as different, separate people. I made a friend in college named Clara, and while by our senior year I no longer lifted my head when I heard someone call her, I could never bring myself to address her directly by name. I think for the rest of my life, when I say those two syllables, my tongue will stick ever so slightly in my mouth.
 
When I arrived at home at the beginning of this trip, my mother had been excited to show me a picture that Christopher’s care team had sent earlier that week. In the picture, he stood, guitar in hand, next to somebody playing piano, their face blurred out for privacy.
 
He has his phone back now that he’s advanced to the looser surveillance levels of the program, and I’ve talked to him once or twice. I called him on his birthday, surprised at the gruff voice that picked up after a few rings. It had been a brief call, the conversation devolving within minutes from standard cookie-cutter greetings to the same awkward silences I’d grown accustomed to over drinks with old high school friends when everyone visited our hometown during the holidays. It seemed that no matter how much we laughed, or how much alcohol was consumed, these kinds of conversations never fully escape the suffocating self-consciousness of what had once been.
 
When I saw Christopher’s picture that day, the size of a playing card on my mother’s phone, I had thought, for the briefest moment, that I was being shown a picture of myself. His hair had been cut into a nearly-trendy shag, converging by pure coincidence with my own style, grown out for the first time since transitioning. The last time I saw him he had been so bony, with adolescent collar bones sticking like wings out of his chest, but now his shoulders are broad and full. While my own body’s changes had come slowly enough that I barely registered the difference, I looked at that picture on my mother’s phone and was struck with the thought that if Christopher and I were to stand next to each other, we would now look like two men, like brothers.
 
Popham Beach has changed since the last time I was here, the shoreline resculpted by a dozen winters and two unsentimental nor’easters. The drop-off is not quite as steep at points, steeper at others, and the bend in the shoreline is now just over ninety degrees. As we run on the firm sand at the water’s edge, the bend comes and goes—our pace is fast and the beach is shorter than I remembered. Before I know it, we are back at the pocket of sand nestled against that strait of calm water.
 
I pause, out of breath, aware of the blisters already forming on the unaccustomed soles of my feet, and look out toward the island. I wade into the water to cool down, and am surprised to discover that it’s much darker and deeper than I remember. The island itself also seems farther away, the scene somehow different, though I can’t identify any concrete change: The pine trees are still tall and neatly pruned, and the path still winds up the barren oceanside greenery of sea roses and shore-grass. The mansion, if you could call it that, still stands, a large house starkly white against the blue of the sky, its many windows dark as ever.
 
Now, though, it doesn’t emit the same air of mystique it once did. The closed windows just look like evidence that the rich out-of-towners, who no doubt own this house, have gone home for the week, and it’s hard to imagine anything beyond squirrels and an older white couple from Connecticut climbing up the path. I squint, willing my contacts to bend just so to allow the light rays to catch my pupils, and restore the perfect vision of my childhood so I might once again see the laser-sharp fantasy of royalty and mythical creatures among the pines. But the gentle waves lap against my stomach, my bare chest glows warm with the sun, and the island lies silent and uninhabited across the strait.
 
I dive under the surface, pushing with my legs and holding my breath like I was born underwater. Its coolness slides around me, a familiar soft touch, and I exhale, suspended in this dark womb between land and air. When I resurface, I can almost imagine, for the briefest moment before I take a breath and open my eyes, that I have emerged on the other side of the strait.
 
“Calvin, do you want to go back or keep going?” My mother calls out from the shore, just a few feet away, splashing herself with water to cool off.
 
“Let’s keep going.”

 

*

 

Christopher lives 1603 miles away from my house in a state I have never visited, and my own house is 542 miles from the island on Popham Beach. He got his GED and works a few hours a day at a coffee shop downtown. We exchange a few texts every once in a while, sending a song we think the other might like, or the password to an old shared account. We talk about planning a visit, but neither one of us seems willing to commit to the trip. I type out the same “for sure, one of these days!” that I’ve sent many times before, but wishing, instead, that I could tell him I could walk down to the path at the end of my dead-end street, down to the docks and wade into the river that passes through this city that has become my new home. I could swim down the river splashing from tributary to tributary, from lake to pond, heading inland across the country, until I reach him.
 
He is taller than me now, but I am stronger than I was. I would lift him onto my broad back, though I cannot remember the last time we’ve touched, and strap a snorkel around his face in case the water splashes up. We would swim, the two of us, me with my favorite butterfly stroke and him holding on tight, and I’d make sure his face never dipped below the surface. We’d swim from pond to lake, from tributary to tributary, and up the river across the country until we reached the ocean. And we would walk to where the shoreline now bends just over ninety degrees, and down the wide expanse of sand to the water’s edge. We would step off the sandbank and swim across the narrow strait, in that clear, flat water—we’d swam two thousand miles, what’s a couple more? We would swim to the island, and finally, after all these years, we would climb up that path through those perfect pines to the enchanted mansion, Christopher and I.

 
 

Nilo Navarro

Nilo Navarro lives and grew up in New England, where he is currently working toward a Master's degree in Mental Health Counseling. He enjoys thinking, reading, and writing about queer relationships and identities, family, nature, and many other topics.

About Chelsea Jackson

Nilo Navarro lives and grew up in New England, where he is currently working toward a Master's degree in Mental Health Counseling. He enjoys thinking, reading, and writing about queer relationships and identities, family, nature, and many other topics.